When it comes to finding top-tier seafood in the Bronx, there’s an exciting variety of restaurants that cater to seafood lovers of all kinds. Whether you’re craving lobster, shrimp, or freshly caught fish, this borough has some hidden gems that will leave you coming back for more. As a food truck fanatic, I’ve explored some of the best seafood spots here, where the freshness and flavors are beyond comparison. Let’s dive in and explore the top restaurants for seafood enthusiasts in the Bronx.
1. Crosstown Diner: A Must for Seafood Lovers
At the top of our list is Crosstown Diner, an iconic Bronx establishment that has been serving locals and visitors for years. This diner offers a wide variety of seafood dishes, ensuring there’s something for every seafood enthusiast in the Bronx. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic fish and chips or want to splurge on a rich lobster tail, Crosstown Diner’s seafood menu is packed with flavorful options.
Located conveniently near the Westchester Square area, this diner isn’t just about your typical seafood. Their famous seafood platter, featuring shrimp, scallops, and clams, is a fan favorite. They pride themselves on fresh ingredients and generous portions, making Crosstown Diner an easy choice for those looking for both comfort and quality. Not to mention, their friendly service and relaxed atmosphere make it a perfect spot for casual dining.
For anyone seeking the perfect combination of Bronx culture and top-notch seafood, Crosstown Diner is your go-to.
2. City Island Lobster House: A Seafood Paradise
Next on the list is a staple for seafood lovers all around New York—City Island Lobster House. Located on City Island, which is known for its seaside vibe and an abundance of seafood joints, this restaurant takes seafood dining to the next level. The freshness of the dishes here is unbeatable, with options ranging from whole lobsters to king crab legs and everything in between.
City Island Lobster House is perfect for seafood enthusiasts in the Bronx who want an upscale yet relaxed dining experience. Their raw bar, offering fresh oysters and clams, is a must-try for seafood purists. Plus, with stunning water views and a robust menu filled with seafood classics, it’s no wonder City Island is a seafood destination for people across the boroughs.
3. Seafood City: Family-Friendly and Flavor-Packed
For a more casual, family-friendly option, Seafood City offers both excellent seafood and an entertaining atmosphere. Located right at the heart of City Island, Seafood City is the perfect stop for families and large groups who are looking for outdoor seating and unbeatable waterfront views. Their fried seafood platters are legendary, with crispy calamari, fried shrimp, and whole fried fish taking center stage.
Beyond their famous fried dishes, Seafood City also offers a range of grilled options for a healthier twist. Their crab cakes are often talked about, and their extensive menu has something for everyone, even the pickiest of eaters. If you’re a seafood enthusiast in the Bronx, this is a spot you won’t want to miss.
4. Lobster Box Restaurant: A Bronx Staple for Seafood
Another favorite on City Island is the Lobster Box Restaurant, which has earned a stellar reputation for its lobster-focused menu and inviting atmosphere. If lobster is your go-to seafood, this restaurant won’t disappoint. Offering everything from lobster bisque to whole steamed lobsters, the Lobster Box knows how to cater to its seafood-loving clientele.
Lobster rolls are particularly popular here, as are the baked clams. While this spot also offers steak and chicken dishes, the real draw is the fresh seafood. They source their ingredients locally when possible, and their seafood pasta dishes are some of the best in the Bronx. The Lobster Box is a great spot for date nights or family outings when you want something a little more upscale.
5. The Original Crab Shanty: A Seafood Institution
Known for its hearty portions and laid-back vibe, The Original Crab Shanty is one of City Island’s most popular seafood restaurants. With a focus on crab dishes, this spot is ideal for those who can’t resist cracking open a freshly steamed crab. Whether you’re digging into a crab boil or savoring their delicious stuffed shrimp, this restaurant guarantees a seafood feast.
The Original Crab Shanty has been around for decades, and its commitment to fresh seafood and bold flavors has made it a local favorite. Their seafood Alfredo is a hit, combining creamy pasta with perfectly cooked shrimp and crab. If you’re a seafood enthusiast in the Bronx, this is one restaurant that should be on your radar.
6. Artie’s Steak & Seafood: A Balanced Menu for All
While primarily known for its steaks, Artie’s Steak & Seafood also offers a fantastic array of seafood dishes, making it a great choice for mixed parties of seafood lovers and meat eaters alike. The seafood options here are extensive, ranging from jumbo shrimp cocktails to baked stuffed lobster. Artie’s is particularly beloved for its generous portions and attentive service.
For those who want variety, Artie’s offers seafood towers, a highlight of the menu, featuring lobster, shrimp, clams, and oysters. This makes it the perfect place to celebrate a special occasion or to indulge in an unforgettable seafood feast. Plus, their outdoor seating in the warmer months adds to the overall experience, allowing you to enjoy the flavors of the ocean while soaking in the Bronx atmosphere.
7. Sammy’s Fish Box: Generous Portions and Big Flavors
Lastly, we can’t forget Sammy’s Fish Box, another City Island hotspot known for its larger-than-life portions and varied seafood offerings. Sammy’s is all about big flavors and even bigger plates. Their seafood combo platters are excellent for sharing, featuring everything from snow crab legs to fried shrimp and lobster tail.
Sammy’s is a great option if you want to try a little bit of everything. Their clambake is a crowd-pleaser, loaded with mussels, clams, lobster, and more. With a long-standing reputation for great service and quality food, Sammy’s Fish Box is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in the Bronx.
Final Thoughts
The Bronx may not be the first borough that comes to mind when thinking of seafood, but it’s home to some truly exceptional spots. Whether you’re dining at the iconic Crosstown Diner or indulging in the ocean’s finest at City Island’s renowned establishments, seafood enthusiasts in the Bronx have plenty of options to explore. From casual fried fish platters to decadent lobster feasts, these restaurants prove that you don’t have to go far to enjoy top-notch seafood.
No matter what kind of seafood you’re craving, the Bronx has a spot for you. Whether you’re a local or visiting from another borough, these seafood havens promise a memorable dining experience.
